74 replies to this topic

[Who's That Guy?]

Pretty simple question, which was the better final?

The other thread didn't have a poll.

[love machine]

For me it was NY. I hated every single aspect of Journey except for BR, which was incredible. I enjoyed a lot of NY.

[FallenAngelII]

"New York" was terrible. And unless "Journey" wins 4 to 1 or something, I'm gonna be very disappointed.

[General Schuester]

Journey any given day. It was exciting, there was focus on every relationship. This finale was a complete lackluster, to the extreme.

It was boring, predictable, and very anti-climactic.

[JKos]

Journey by far.

Go look at the threads in the Journey episode section and then look at the threads in here.

[Who's That Guy?]

Journey by far.

Go look at the threads in the Journey episode section and then look at the threads in here.

I remember how excited everyone was after Journey. The fandom exploded.

[love machine]

I hated Journey so much

[Who's That Guy?]

I hated Journey so much

Sorry. I should have said BUT Jesse/St Berry/Pukelberry fans

[glorifiedgleek]

Journey

[love machine]

Sorry. I should have said BUT Jesse/St Berry/Pukelberry fans

Hahahahahaha yup. I've really tried to like it though, I've rewatched a few times and I just can't do it I remember sitting watching it (I was at a sleepover and I left the room for an hour to watch this) and being incredibly mad. It was soooo cheesy it was painful.

Erryone else loved it

[gleekfreak15]

Oh that's a hard one...

They were both so good! I think I liked New York better though. My new favorite episode

However, I loved VA's performance last year better than this year. Sorry Charice, but no one does it like Jon Groff

[GleeRachelBerry]

I would say Journey, but then I think about Hummelberry and their performance, and then I have to go with NY.

[FallenAngelII]

I would say Journey, but then I think about Hummelberry and their performance, and then I have to go with NY.

Ignore that one number and look at thee pacing, the plot and the general "season finale" feel. Don't be blinded by singular brilliant numbers with almost zero impact on the plot!

[Noah Puckerman]

Simply put... Journey had me in tears, New York had me annoyed (minus Wicked).

[IWontApologizeForWhoIAm]

i definitely say Journey, i dont hate New York but it didnt match up to Journey. Like someone said before, they dealt with every relationship... Ahh, i miss the Glee that made sense.

[Willfanxx]

New York

[Earwen]

Sorry. I should have said BUT Jesse/St Berry/Pukelberry fans

:-/ I'm a St.Berry-Season1-shipper and Jesse fan and Journey's still one of my favorite episodes. I really don't like those generalizations.

So yeah, definitely "Journey" for me. It was way too cheesy, but "Bohemian Rhapsody" is my favorite scene ever, I actually liked Finn this episode (never once saying "I told you so" about Jesse or resent Rachel for not accepting him in "Laryngitis" was really cool imo) and therefore didn't mind Finchel, the Journey mash-up was a lot better than those original songs, I loved Sue and the judge's scene etc.

[Chord Overstreet]

New York!

Twas magical

[superbatgirl]

This one, New York, I really didn't like Journey, except the few Finchel moments we had gotten. Also, Klaine.

[Mike]

Journey made me cry, this made me smile and anxiously die for the Brittana scene at the end.

As far as emotional impact, Bohemian Rhapsody combined with Quinn's birth is pretty damn hard to compete against. New York was amazing though, felt like a movie more than an episode.