58 replies to this topic

[KurtBlaine4Ever]

it seemed a bit unclear.

[Ehmyglee]

it seemed a bit unclear.

yes its the thing he told quinn its such a dumb thing that the creators did that

[Bruce Wayne]

no they held hands.

[Luis]

I'm going to be sick...
*shudders, shudders everywhere*

[bigdaddyt4]

I took from it that they almost did but didn't

[Cadiva]

I'm fairly sure the implication was that yes Puck and Shelby had sex and that's why she said it was a mistake and asked him to leave.

[KurtBlaine4Ever]

I took from it that they almost did but didn't

yea, it kinda seems like that to me.

[EmmaSchu]

I was also confused. But I'm assuming Puck wouldn't just confide "I have a crush on Rachel's mom" to Quinn and have her react the way she did.

Quinn is 100 kinds of batsh*t crazy, but at least she recognizes how messed up this is.

On another note, it's slightly disturbing that the guy who makes the most sense and finally tells Quinn what she needs to hear -- she's INSANE and MESSED UP -- is the kid who had sex with his ex-girlfriend's mother.

[lightningpr0ductions]

I think they did, since she referred to it as a "mistake". They've already kissed, so the next step would be to sleep together.

Honestly, I don't really care. I just can't wait until this story line is over.

[General Schuester]

This plot is clearly not going anywhere. It is unresolved and although Shelby says what she says to Quinn in episode 8(not loving Puck) after Constant Craving I think its clear she is lying.

[EmmaSchu]

I'm fairly sure the implication was that yes Puck and Shelby had sex and that's why she said it was a mistake and asked him to leave.

From a few episodes ago?? If so, I'm not sure simply because he told her that Shelby had been avoiding them ever since they "made out." His whole thing has been "this is going to happen," and since they had already kissed at that point, I was assuming he was talking about sex.

In the end, I'm just grateful they weren't explicit about it and decided not to show it. I can only hold down my vomit so long.

[Cadiva]

From a few episodes ago?? If so, I'm not sure simply because he told her that Shelby had been avoiding them ever since they "made out." His whole thing has been "this is going to happen," and since they had already kissed at that point, I was assuming he was talking about sex.

In the end, I'm just grateful they weren't explicit about it and decided not to show it. I can only hold down my vomit so long.

No, from tonight's episode.

[MamaShante]

i'm ready to move on from this storyline! i want shelby and rachel!! yay! how many more episodes does idina have left on glee?

[Cassie July]

I personally found even more uncomfortable the fact that Shelby, a grown woman, called Puck in the middle of his school hours. I could have understand if had been Quinn.

[KurtBlaine4Ever]

i'm ready to move on from this storyline! i want shelby and rachel!! yay! how many more episodes does idina have left on glee?

she siged up for 12. i think she did like 5/6 so far

[Pen]

This plot is clearly not going anywhere. It is unresolved and although Shelby says what she says to Quinn in episode 8(not loving Puck) after Constant Craving I think its clear she is lying.

I don't think she loves him, but she obviously has feelings for him. Shelby is all kinds of messed up as it is and the scare with Beth had her emotions on overdrive. That and the fact that Puck was there for her and strong in the situation . . .

But I still . . . just . . . cant.

[EmmaSchu]

No, from tonight's episode.

Wow, I must have been really distracted because I did not see this scene at all.

Then going by that, then yes, they definitely had sex. I don't think it was necessary in order for us to figure that out what with "I have to tell you something" and Quinn's clear disgust, but that makes it more concrete.

[nyislesfan]

Yeah they did. He said he was still young so he could go 4 more times.

[Luis]

Yeah they did. He said he was still young so he could go 4 more times.

Oh god. If he really said that, that definitely isn't one of my favorite quotes from this episode.

[MamaShante]

she siged up for 12. i think she did like 5/6 so far

S W E E T!! i hope the rest of the episodes will be soley be for her and rachel!!